Roosting chickens going headless
Friday, May 9th, 2008
The 1970 election was won by the Conservatives against all the accepted wisdom. Harold Wilson was the calm and effective communicator, Ted Heath the unelectable Selsdon Man. Then in 1992 the Conservatives were due to lose. But against the odds and the conventional wisdom, a Conservative Government was re-elected.
In the United States, Hillary Clinton was written off in the New Hampshire primary. Two days ago we kept hearing erroneously how she was narrowing the gap in North Carolina and was well ahead in Indiana. We heard how disconsolate Barack Obama was, as blue-collar workers were deserting him. Now we know what was actually happening.
Electorates do sometimes spring surprises, despite the sophistication of psephologists. However this is not normally the case when the weather really changes, and when Governments run out of steam.
Now in Britain we may see the stirrings of economic revival in two years time, or we may not. It is a known unknown. However the extraordinary personal unpopularity of the Prime Minister, and the fact that the problems of contemporary Britain are all too often products of Government failure itself, suggests that the weather – like this week – has changed. In their hearts this is what Labour MPs feel too. And even if the Sun poll this morning exaggerates the situation, it simply illustrates this fact, based upon what MPs’ constituents are telling them.
This really was the week that was.
Nothing said more last week about a certain detachment from reality than the pre local elections Newsnight interview of my parliamentary colleague and our local government spokesman, Eric Pickles. He is very calm, professional, experienced and indeed very funny. Newsnight’s penetrating insight into voters’ attitudes was a photograph of young Oxford undergraduates in tailcoats. The inference was that this would surely turn off voters. Well now we know otherwise. Eric pointed out that this simply represented an obsession of some journalists, and that quite rightly nobody ever raised any of this on the doorstep.
Rab Butler, the once nearly Prime Minister, used to say that he learned most about the mood of the nation from the station master at Saffron Walden when he arrived in his constituency for the weekend. It is a worthwhile observation.